Ranking Member Takano After Oracle Hearing: No Answers on $17.5 Billion, and Ellison is Next
Press Contact
Mike Lavigne (Communications Director)
Elain Shubat (Deputy Communications Director/Digital Director)
WASHINGTON – House Veterans’ Affairs Committee Ranking Member Mark Takano (CA-39) released the following statement after today’s full committee hearing with Oracle CEO Mike Sicilia and Oracle Health Executive Vice President Seema Verma. Sicilia appeared under subpoena after refusing to appear at the Committee’s September 2 hearing.
“After yet another hearing on VA’s electronic health record, I am no more confident in this program, and I did not hear a justification for the $17.5 billion increase in its cost,” said Ranking Member Takano. “In September, VA blamed Oracle. Today, Oracle pointed the finger back at VA. Nobody wants to take responsibility, but both want a blank check from taxpayers while veterans are being harmed.”
On Oracle’s contract: Asked by Rep. Maggie Goodlander (NH-02)whether Oracle kept its 2022 promise to this Committee to bear cost overruns, Sicilia said, “I don’t believe the promise was broken.” Asked by Rep. Julia Brownley (CA-26) roughly how much Oracle has absorbed, however, neither Sicilia nor Verma could give a figure. Verma said, “I don’t have a rough estimate in front of me.” The contract ceiling has gone from about $10 billion to about $27 billion, and the system is live at 19 of 170 sites, or 11 percent. This led Rep. Herb Conaway (NJ-03), an internal medicine specialist, to ask,“Why is Oracle charging the VA so much more for the same work that Cerner did before you bought it?”
On patient safety: Asked by Rep. Kelly Morrison (MN-03), an obstetrician-gynecologist, why taxpayers should accept the increase while patient safety concerns remain unresolved, Sicilia said he is “not aware of any direct patient safety concerns that are yet unresolved.” VA’s own data, cited at the hearing by Rep. Goodlander, show 4,601 cases of harm involving the system, 10 of them classified as catastrophic. “There are five other deaths directly accountable to the EHR system that you are deploying,” said Rep. Maxine Dexter (OR-03), a pulmonologist. "The fact that we are only in 19 of 170 facilities, and we are continuing to fund this, knowing people are dying, is absolutely on our heads and we need to do something about it.”
On veterans’ data: Rep. Nikki Budzinski (IL-13), ranking member of the Technology Modernization Subcommittee, told Sicilia and Verma it was her understanding that Oracle’s sales team has been pursuing the inclusion of its commercial terms and conditions on data privacy, “which would virtually allow you to own this data.” “Do you believe Oracle should be able to stand above statutory protections for veterans’ data so you can improve your bottom line?” Rep. Budzinski asked. Verma answered, “We have zero access to the data of the veterans… We do not use that data for any purpose.” RM Takano then told them VA staff described a “long, feisty discussion” with Oracle on exactly that.
On Larry Ellison. Sicilia acknowledged he never asked Larry Ellison directly whether Ellison had spoken with the President or White House officials about Oracle’s VA contract. “I did not ask him directly,” he said.
“Without that information, I am still unconvinced that Larry Ellison’s relationship with the president has not tipped the scales in Oracle’s favor,” RM Takano said. “I do expect to see Larry Ellison on December 10, as required by Dr. Dexter’s unanimous subpoena. Continued pressure from Oracle’s lobbyists will not result in us looking the other way.”
On Oracle meeting the contract terms. After being asked directly by RM Takano, Sicilia committed to Oracle owning the health record business through 2031, then added, “I can’t imagine there’d be a lot of buyers that signed up to take on this program right now.”
“If I read a headline that Oracle is selling off this business, it’s going to look like you fooled us twice,” RM Takano told him.
Takano entered into the hearing record Oracle’s responses to the Committee’s pre-hearing requests and email communications between Oracle’s sales team and the contracting team at VA’s Technology Acquisition Center, which handled the $17.5 billion contract augmentation.
“Oracle has not delivered what it promised for veterans,” RM Takano said. “Taxpayers should not be asked to keep sending good money to a failed program until Mr. Sicilia’s and Mr. Ellison’s promises are fulfilled.”
RM Takano and Democratic Members of the Committee have asked Oracle to produce all documents and communications with White House and VA officials about its work at VA. The Committee will hear from Oracle Chairman Larry Ellison next month.
###
Previous Article